How do you picture me in your mind?

Headline Story
6

My name is Rosabel. My husband and I have lived here nine years with our two vivacious, intellectually curious, and fun-loving children. When my children were preschoolers, you might have seen them riding their balance bikes at Parsons Park or Greenridge Park. When I was a volunteer music instructor for two years at Chabot Elementary, you might have heard me singing weekly with the beautiful voices of 75 children. Before COVID-19, you might have seen us visiting the library, collecting food donations with Cub Scouts, or serving Sunday breakfast to our neighbors in need at First Presbyterian.

How do you picture me in your mind?

What if I told you my full name? Rosabel Chang.

What do you think I look like now? Does it change what you think of me?

If you surmise that I am of Chinese descent, you are correct.

“Where are you really from?” is a question I’ve been asked too often in my life.

Or, “You speak English so well.” I wonder: Why wouldn’t I speak English well? Would it matter if I didn’t?

In front of my (bi-racial) children at a Castro Valley playground, I was asked: “Are you their nanny?”

Yet none of this prejudice prepared me for the blatant, painful racism my parents have faced in the last month when they looked for rental units in Castro Valley. My parents, retired and excited to finally live close to their grandchildren, have ethnic sounding names and speak fluent but accented English. Roughly ten properties would not return their repeated voicemails. The units remained available, but no call backs.

As a test, we asked my husband to leave voicemails shortly after my parents did. My husband is white with an Anglo-Saxon name (David Moler) and impeccable English.

What do you think happened?

It was disappointingly predictable. My husband received prompt call backs. Clearly, apartment and townhome complexes in the heart of Castro Valley do not abide by fair housing laws. When called-out by my husband and my father on their visits, the managers hemmed and hawed and sidestepped their discriminatory practices.

Before George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, and rising racial assaults against Asian Americans driven by the President’s derogatory labeling of COVID-19 as the ‘China plague,’ I am embarrassed to admit that I probably would have remained silent and resigned. For many of us who have suffered discrimination our entire lives, this is how we have survived. I would have considered finding another place to call home.

NO MORE. ENOUGH. This is my home. This is my town. This is in my country. My family is here to stay. Castro Valley is changing, and it is changing for the better. I know many of you share my disgust and outrage towards racism. To all those in our community who do: Stand with me. Use your voices. Use your pens. Use your social media platforms. Use your power. Do not be silent. Stand up for what is right. There is no place for racism or hate in Castro Valley.

Rosabel, thank you for the eye-opening commentary. I’m holding you and your family in my heart — and I’m truly hoping that that “hemming and hawing” rental agent has a heart open to learning and personal growth. I’m proud to share this community with you.

Wow, what a beautifully written letter and so sad. I admire Rosabel and think that she is so courageous for bringing this to light. I hope that Castro Valley becomes a better place for those who have been discrimated against.

Beautiful and so well written. We moved to Castro Valley in a similar time frame in haste as we were being kicked out of our previous housing. We knew little about Castro Valley since we are not from the bay area. It did not take long before I started having second thoughts due to a history of racism here that I was previously unaware. Some of that definitely still lingers, like the family who flew the Nazi flag near Creekside Middle School a few years ago but I have been so impressed with most of the people I have met here. As a coach, I am particularly impressed with the students I have interacted with at the schools.

I love how you introduce your family with “You might have seen….” You might have seen me and my daughters riding our bicycles for recreation and transportation around town. A lot of people recognize us because we are so visible and exposed. For years, when I met someone new they would start out with, “Are you that guy on the bike with those 2 girls?” One time I had some kids tell me all about this guy who rides his bike with these 2 girls but they did not recognize me without my “props”–too funny. Getting out into the community is the best way to create a sense of well being and safety.

You also really hooked me with “How do you picture me…” since I just finished watching a documentary “Picture a Scientist”, where they challenge the notion that scientist must be male. Well worth watching. Thanks again for your poignant words.

Dear Rosabel Chang,
Thank you very much for speaking out in the local Castro Valley Forum about your parent’s encountering current racial discrimination in the Castro Valley real estate rental market. It made me so sad, so angry, and so needing to shout out. I know you as my good neighbor, and I’m so ashamed that we are treating you and your parents in such an insulting manner.

I loved moving to “multi-racial” Castro Valley 16 years ago after 35 years of living in mostly “white” Pacifica. I thought Castro Valley was a wonderful blend of races and nationalities, as seen at our local Chabot Elementary School. Our Castro Valley street is a wonderfully blended mixture of color and race. Before COVID-19, in early March, I attended a fantastic multi-cultural food and culture fest by students and parents at Vannoy Elementary School, featuring a performance in Spanish by the Mariachi Voces del Valle, comprised of Castro Valley Unified School District Students. What a source of local pride that was!

But, with the national unrest and emphasis on “Black Lives Matter” and equality of races generally, I started reading many books that showed our history of and continuing acceptance of white supremacy. I spent time with my black friend of many years, discussing her family’s being the constant target of prejudicial actions in Southern California and in the Bay Area. I started looking for nearby signs of white supremacy. The first thing I noticed was that the half sheet photo spread of y Bay Area Real Estate brokers and salespeople was a sea of white, and, for the first time, this really worried me.

I then read a revealing 2019 report on the history of racially exclusionary housing in the San Francisco Bay Area, with a discussion of current “traces of the past”: https://belonging.berkeley.edu/rootsraceplace. And, I thought that what Rosabel Chang has encountered through her Chinese parents’ inability to get even a call-back from ten Castro Valley rental properties, might be the beginnings of a white-only resurgence in my Castro Valley and the East Bay.

Please, Castro Valley owners of rental properties and please, Castro Valley Realtors, fight bigotry! Fight racism! Encourage acceptance!
Liz Baker, aka GrammieLiz

Rosabel – your parents must be so proud of you in speaking up against the incredibly unjust and inhumane treatment that your family, and so many families, have endured for far too long. Thank you for speaking up, for setting an example, for inviting all of us to look into our hearts, our minds, our souls, and take stock. It’s time for all of us to learn, to unlearn, to understand, to speak up and to step forward. I’m sorry that your pain is part of all of our paths forward, but please feel our gratitude, our shame, and our resolve to make things right. The Castro Valley community, and beyond, can do this. Thank you for lighting the way.

Education
5
The Many Loves of Donald “Dobie” Gelles

Love him or leave him, Dobie made his mark in Castro Valley through his love of education and our community.

Alameda County
6
A freeway would run through it: Reflecting on the history of the 238 parcels and who decides their future

Over 50 years ago, the State of California “purchased more than 400 parcels of property for construction of a 14-mile 238 Corridor Bypass Freeway to run through the City of Hayward and parts of unincorporated Alameda County.” Many people fought the project since its inception in 1961. Sustained activism and …

Featured Story
1
“We fight darkness with light”

Last Saturday morning my colleague in Poway had a day that began similarly to that of many Rabbis. He welcomed a larger than normal crowd into his Synagogue. It was Shabbat, Passover and a day on which Jews recite the Yizkor (memorial) prayer. He led the services and directed the …