What is the Castro Valley Municipal Advisory Council (MAC), Anyway?

Governance
13

What is the Castro Valley Municipal Advisory Council (MAC)?

Many locals have been mystified about this group.  Rumors abound as to their powers, motives, and how they come to power.  What’s the real truth?

But first, what exactly IS a Municipal Advisory Council (MAC)? 

The State Legislature passed a law in 1971 that allowed California counties to establish Municipal Advisory Councils for unincorporated communities. MACs were created to give a new level of self-governance to unincorporated communities and provide county governments with a better understanding of community needs and wants. County governments find it very difficult to offer unincorporated areas the same levels of services that cities receive.  Incorporation would naturally solve that problem, but in many areas incorporation is either not wanted or not feasible.

MACs are defined in California State Code Section 31010:

“The board of supervisors of any county may by resolution
establish and provide funds for the operation of a municipal advisory
council for any unincorporated area in the county to advise the
board on such matters which relate to that area as may be designated
by the board concerning services which are or may be provided to the
area by the county or other local governmental agencies, including
but not limited to advice on matters of public health, safety,
welfare, public works, and planning. Unless the board of supervisors
specifically provides to the contrary, a municipal advisory council
may represent the community to any state, county, city, special
district or school district, agency or commission, or any other
organization on any matter concerning the community. The board may
pay from available funds such actual and necessary expenses of
travel, lodging, and meals for the members of the council while on
such official business as may be approved by the board.”

This state law allows Counties to create MACs which vary widely in their scopes and structures. The county Board of Supervisors is authorized under 31010 to decide if a MAC will be appointed or elected. Although originally intended as a preliminary step towards incorporation (as happened in East Palo Alto, Windsor, Apple Valley and Hesperia among others) they have evolved more into permanent tools for community participation in unincorporated communities.

What is the Castro Valley MAC?
The original county resolution which created the Castro Valley MAC

Alameda County Board of Supervisors resolution on April 7, 1981 established the Castro Valley MAC.

The original resolution states that the MAC is to “advise the Board of Supervisors on matters concerning the government by said Board of that area known as Castro Valley.” It goes on to state “Such advice to the Board of Supervisors shall be on all matters concerning services which are or may be provided to said area by the County or other local governmental agencies, including but not limited to advice on matters of public safety, welfare, public works and planning.”

Originally, the five members were appointed to one year terms appointed by the District Four Supervisor.  That has been amended over the years, most recently in 2010, and now there are seven  members who are appointed to four year terms, not to exceed twelve years of consecutive service (which is the term limit for all Alameda County Boards and Commissions.)  Members must be residents of Castro Valley or be an “active” Castro Valley business owner, and continue to be for the duration of their term.

Currently, the council has two Land Use meetings on the second and fourth Monday of each month, and a General Purpose meeting on the third Monday of the Month.  Land use meetings generally deal with planning and zoning issues, while General Purpose deal with other issues.  Council Members receive a $50 per diem payment for every meeting, and the Council is limited to no more than 30 meetings per year. Members receive no other compensation or benefits for their work.

At land use meetings, the MAC reviews conditional use permits, zoning exceptions that allow property owners to use land in a way not otherwise permitted within a particular area, and forwards its recommendations to the West County Board of Zoning Adjustments (BZA), who makes the final decision.   The BZA also reviews site development plans and many other land use and zoning issues, considering input from the MAC.

At general purpose meetings, the MAC considers many other local issues, many at the direct request of District 4 Supervisor Nate Miley.

It is important to note that the Castro Valley MAC has no binding powers at all. Legally, it functions purely in an advisory capacity.  The MAC makes recommendations to the Board of Supervisors and other County agencies, but they are under no obligation to accept its advice, and often do not.

The Castro Valley MAC is not a particularly mysterious group, but they have been misunderstood by many.  They have a very important role in our virtual town, and they act as the collective voice of Castro Valley to Nate Miley, and the rest of the elected County government. Their opinions and recommendations are seriously considered when decisions about us are made.

Try to make it to a MAC meeting, and learn about how local governance works in Castro Valley.

If you can’t make it to MAC meetings, you can often follow them live on Twitter with #MACmtg hashtag, or catch a recap of MAC meetings here on the Castro Valley Matters blog.

mac3
The current members of the Castro Valley MAC.

 

Hi Michael,
Informative post! I have found that having a MAC gives us, the citizens of CV, a place where we can bring our concerns to a public forum. Most issue that are brought forward are referred either to the appropriate agency or are put on the agenda for a future meeting.

Whether the members are appointed or elected we the citizens of Castro Valley have a place to go so that our voices are heard.

I have 2 questions. What would it cost to have an election for MAC members every 2 years?
If the laws in Sacramento regarding the distribution of tax dollars were to change and it became favorable to community incorporation efforts, What would it cost for a new incorporation effort in Castro Valley?
Bob Swanson – CV resident

Thanks, Bob!

According to the most recent “Guide to the LAFCO Process for Incorporations” published by the State (from 2002), they say “it is not unusual for an incorporation to cost more than $100,000.” You can read the whole report here: https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0CCAQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fopr.ca.gov%2Fdocs%2FLAFCO_October_21_guidelines.pdf&ei=3YDuU_6uGsPtoAS68YG4Cw&usg=AFQjCNG-5MDMOI6nsy5akTJME0nr-wjqzA&sig2=oegTiInwQ3oefRHykT5Bvw

As for the cost of MAC elections, that’s a good question to pose to the County Registrar of voters. That was brought up at the last EALI Governance meeting. I’ll research and we’ll get back to you!

Once again, very informative. Thank you.

It was not that long ago when the press had enough staff to research major issues in the incorporated area. We had competition between the Daily Review and the Oakland Tribune. I miss it.
Bob Swanson – CV resident

Michael,

Excellent explanation of what a MAC does!

I appreciate Bob Swanson’s questions about the costs
of incorporation and an elected MAC.
The costs are critical to reviewing and discussing the options
with the community.

I also miss the news reporting. Wouldn’t it be great if the
CV Matters posts were printed in the CV Forum?

Since you have done the leg work writing the articles,
the Forum could print them at minimal cost. No reporter needed,
just an editor.

Some educational and objective articles informing
people about their town would be a great community service!
Seems that used to be part of the mission of the press.

Thanks again for all of your work on this.

Linda Willis, Castro Valley resident

Is this site inactive as there haven’t been any posts for over about a year and a half? In addition, some of the info posted is now out of date. I have some issues pertaining to the conduct of some of the CV MAC’s members but if this site is inactive, then I’m not going to waste my time here.

Tom Hervey

The site is active, we just have had some recent technical difficulties. There are some recent posts and will be publishing a few new posts soon.

Sir,
Amazing information thank you so much.

Now where can I find a list of MAC’s to see if this town has one or not

Thank you

Governance
Supervisors to hear proposal for incorporation fiscal analysis

The Alameda County Board of Supervisors Unincorporated Services Committee meets on Wednesday, April 27 at 6:00 pm to hear from the Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCo) about a proposed fiscal analysis of the feasibility of incorporating Castro Valley and the other Alameda County unincorporated communities.

This is a map of the location of Castro Valley Lumber
Community
6
Chick-fil-A next to Burger Island? Where’s the beef?

When you consider how this location is a gateway to this community, how poorly conceived this intersection is, and the increasing traffic along 580, it is fair to question the wisdom of placing a new drive-thru restaurant here.

Governance
Crawford to resign from MAC, be appointed to Alameda County Planning Commission

Supervisor Nate Miley has nominated current Castro Valley Municipal Council (MAC) Chair Marc Crawford to serve on the Alameda County Planning Commission, according to the agenda posted for Tuesday’s Board of Supervisors meeting. Crawford’s resignation from the MAC is also included on the agenda. The Planning Commission is made up …